Whats better?

Adept Posts : 1853 Registration date : 2008-08-12

What one of these is better?

1. Whats better? 7gze5

2.

Super-Human Posts : 3040 Registration date : 2009-02-09

thats hard they are very simmalar number 1 probs

Adept Posts : 1913 Registration date : 2008-02-02

#1 is better, The other ones have a plain backround.

Super-Human Posts : 3059 Registration date : 2009-02-08

1 is better.

Vanguard Posts : 4956 Registration date : 2008-01-26

#2

Number 1 has the logo up close and hard to see. The text is not typed out. The background looks too sharp and rough. The gradient differs too much. Lastly, the light does not fit the image because of how the rest of it is made.

Many users overuse this. The light is to add a 3D-ish look, to finish it all off. If the gradient is wrong, the render is too big, or the text looks bad then the light is useless.

Super-Human Posts : 3059 Registration date : 2009-02-08

Jack Frost wrote:: #2

Number 1 has the logo up close and hard to see. The text is not typed out. The background looks too sharp and rough. The gradient differs too much. Lastly, the light does not fit the image because of how the rest of it is made.

Many users overuse this. The light is to add a 3D-ish look, to finish it all off. If the gradient is wrong, the render is too big, or the text looks bad then the light is useless.

I think I agree with you now.

#2 is better! :D

Vanguard Posts : 4319 Registration date : 2008-09-01

Yeah the first one is better. Second one has only one color.

Super-Human Posts : 3059 Registration date : 2009-02-08

this thread should have a poll. ;)

Vagabond Posts : 50 Registration date : 2009-02-16

I think 1 is better.

Adept Posts : 1853 Registration date : 2008-08-12

Jack Frost wrote:: #2

Number 1 has the logo up close and hard to see. The text is not typed out. The background looks too sharp and rough. The gradient differs too much. Lastly, the light does not fit the image because of how the rest of it is made.

Many users overuse this. The light is to add a 3D-ish look, to finish it all off. If the gradient is wrong, the render is too big, or the text looks bad then the light is useless.

having the logo like that makes userbars better, you can still easily tell what it is.

well, the text didnt suit all typed out, the background is only two colours? the gradient is only two colours as well.

fair enough.

thanks for the constructive criticism :D

thanks everyone else.

Paragon Posts : 7260 Registration date : 2008-01-27

#1!! :)

» oh whats the use...
» whats it about?
» Whats Better?
» Whats up!
» whats up