Who is better? (No this shouldnt go in graphic battles)

Super-Human Posts : 3251 Registration date : 2008-02-16

In another forum I was having a sig battle VS someone named Scotland and he won then DK voted for me (He is the best GFXer there) an he got really mad heres a quote

Scotland wrote:: Dieg DK saying that was a one off.

Everyone likes my work more than yours.

Everyone lucky if they can even see yours.

That made me angry seriously so I decided to ask this forum (I guess you already know what forum I'm talking about) here are the sigs that we had

My Sig
Who is better? (No this shouldnt go in graphic battles) HeroSiggeh

Who is better? (No this shouldnt go in graphic battles) HeroSiggeh

His Sig

Who is better? (No this shouldnt go in graphic battles) Lucastoni

Now tell me which is better?

Hero for Hire Posts : 1187 Registration date : 2008-01-25

Scotlands. If you ever need help with graphics you can always ask me via pm.

Super-Human Posts : 3251 Registration date : 2008-02-16

I think Scotland just used clouds and polar inversion but I respect your vote anyways

Sidekick Posts : 614 Registration date : 2008-01-29

Well, If this is best sig, I would Say your's. Only because:

Idieg's
-------------------
Blended: Yes
Color's: O.K.
Lighting: Not Good
Compo: O.K.
Critiqe: More FX, Blurry a little
Comments:Render is blended, Text is little, Sparks

Scotlands
--------------------
Blended: No
Colors: Bad
Lighting: Bad
Compo: O.K.
Critiqe: Pixely Backround, Choppy Render, No Blending, Text is big and Blurry.
Comment: At least knew how to make a sig :P

Form:
Great
Good
O.K.
Not Good
Bad

Pm Me if you ever need help if your using Gimp or just post help inthe shadow GFX thread. :)

Super-Human Posts : 3251 Registration date : 2008-02-16

Wow that was detailed Jake

Thanks for voting for me

Citizen Posts : 240 Registration date : 2008-04-25

I like yours

Paragon Posts : 7114 Registration date : 2008-01-27

Lol Scotland, i know him :D

Adept Posts : 1583 Registration date : 2008-02-02

I chose diegs.

**Hero of Time** Posts : 13850 Registration date : 2008-01-26

Scotland's sig isn't very well rendered, and the coloring is bad, although yours is a little big--overall, yours, though.
~Egaro

Digintary Posts : 2802 Registration date : 2008-04-08

Scotland didn't put much effort into it.
He just used an effects backround but you did much more, iDieg.

I vote you.

giatekla

Pinnacle of Survival Posts : 8155 Registration date : 2008-01-31

Jake pretty much said it.
Idieg gets my vote.

Wanderer Posts : 105 Registration date : 2008-02-11

I choose yours, although it looks like just alot of smudging. Scottland's is just a few effects with a render.

Digintary Posts : 2622 Registration date : 2008-01-27

I think Your's Is Better ;)