Rating Scale

Paragon Posts : 7114 Registration date : 2008-01-27

Just a little reminder on how you should rate others people's tags.

I see a bunch of random things sometimes that dont make any sense.

On a scale of 1/10 rate off these standards:

-Depth (DEPTH) - 1 points
-Flow (does the tag flow, or are the effects and smudges goin everywhere?) - 1 points
-Effects (do the effects contribute to the tag) - 1 points
-Compo - (How good the effect placements are and how well the tag is put together.) - 1 points
-Concept - (The whole idea of the tag, the creativity within the tag.) - 1 point
-Colors - (How well the tag is blended and how well the colors look according to the stock and effects.) - 1 point
-Skill Level (do you think you could make it?)- 1 points
-Lighting (too dark, too bright, etc.)- 1 points
-Smudging (does the smudging blend in the tag or contribute to it?)- 1 points
-Blend(does the render/stock blend in with the effects and background?)- 1 points

So if you dont think that the tag is perfect it wont get all the points in each category. If the tag is amazing it should get around an 8.75-9/10. See you need to deduct points from each category based on the tag. Everyone starts out at a 10/10, if you see no deductions then it remains a 10/10.

Do not rate on:
-If the person is a moderator, or admin
-Who the person is
-Just because it looks cool on the outside, look at the tag and examine it

Dont rate if:
-You have no idea what to say, just say good job, or great effort.
-You really dont understand anything about GFX
-You have something mean to say, CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM PLEASE!

~DirkD

Subject: Re: Rating Scale September 3rd 2008, 11:24 am

Thanks for posting this Cole. I'll sticky this.

Adept Posts : 1859 Registration date : 2008-05-21

Nice, I'd unadd text though text is most of the time never a big issue unless your sig is empty and the text is your focal.

Add these...

Compo - How good the effect placements are and how well the tag is put together.

Concept - The whole idea of the tag, the creativity within the tag.

Colors - How well the tag is blended and how well the colors look according to the stock and effects.

Thats the Triple C. :omg:

Paragon Posts : 7114 Registration date : 2008-01-27

Updated. :)

Subject: Re: Rating Scale September 6th 2008, 1:44 pm

Great thread. ;)

Sidekick Posts : 545 Registration date : 2008-09-22

Just tags? :line:

Paragon Posts : 7114 Registration date : 2008-01-27

Or LP's it really doesnt matter.

Vanguard Posts : 4319 Registration date : 2008-09-01

Good guide. I will remember some of these things as I rate people.

Super-Human Posts : 3179 Registration date : 2008-01-26

Can't we just rate on how good it looks?

XD

Observer Posts : 321 Registration date : 2008-11-04

Eh, not all tags have to have good flow and stuff. I've seen many good tags with no flow at all.

I just wanna point out that you can have a very good sig without all these qualities. color, blending, and others are uneeded.

Super-Human Posts : 3179 Registration date : 2008-01-26

.Emin wrote:: Eh, not all tags have to have good flow and stuff. I've seen many good tags with no flow at all.

I just wanna point out that you can have a very good sig without all these qualities. color, blending, and others are uneeded.

So you're agreeing with me - we can just rate 10 'cos it looks good?

XD

Vanguard Posts : 4378 Registration date : 2008-04-12

Great thread

Subject: Re: Rating Scale April 3rd 2009, 11:45 pm

*cough*
Read when was the last post above you codename
*cough*

» New Toy n' Movie Rating!
» party rating
» cursor rating!
» Modship and Movie Rating!
» ..:Official artwork rating thread:..